Do SEO yourself or outsource it? An honest comparison
Short answer
Doing SEO yourself suits a business owner with time, a small local market and an appetite for learning how search engines work. Outsourcing is a better fit if your hours are scarce, your website is technically complex or your competitors are already strong. A mix is also possible. You then keep the basics and your own copy in your own hands and leave the technical work to a specialist.
DIY and outsourcing side by side
Each route has its strengths and weaknesses. For each element, you can see what a choice demands and what it delivers.
| Component | Doing it yourself | Outsourcing |
|---|---|---|
| Time | You put hours into learning, writing and checking every week. In busy weeks, this work is the first to slip. | The hands-on work lies with someone else. You make time for meetings, feedback and sharing your expertise. |
| Knowledge and skills | You know your customers and your trade best. You pick up the technical side and analysis along the way. | You bring in experience with the technical side and analysis. You supply the knowledge about your customers and services yourself. |
| Tools | For the basics, Google's free tools take you a long way, such as Search Console for your visibility in the search results and your Google Business Profile. | A specialist often works with paid tools for keywords and technical checks. Ask whether those are included in the fee. |
| Types of cost | You mainly pay with your own hours. Subscriptions to paid tools and a course may come on top. | You pay a monthly fee or for a one-off audit. Your hours for meetings count too. |
| Risks | A technical error or the wrong trick can harm your visibility. Sometimes you only spot such an error late. | Google says you are responsible for what a hired company does to your site. So choose carefully. |
| Speed of results | Google says some changes take effect within a few hours, while others need a few months. | Experience saves detours and repair work. Even then, every change needs time. |
| Control and know-how | Everything stays in your own hands and the knowledge grows within your business. If you are busy or away, everything stands still. | You become dependent on a provider. So keep access to Search Console and your website in your own name. |
When to do it yourself and when to outsource?
When deciding whether to outsource SEO or do it yourself, your own situation counts most. Small businesses less often have IT expertise in-house. In the Netherlands, figures from CBS show that in 2020, 14% of businesses employing 10 to 20 people had an ICT specialist on the payroll, compared with 86% of businesses employing 500 or more people.

Do it yourself if β¦
you run a small local business with a straightforward website.
you set aside fixed time every week to work on SEO yourself.
you enjoy learning how Google reads your pages.
you like writing about your trade and know your customers' questions.
Outsource if β¦
your diary is full and SEO keeps ending up at the bottom of your list.
your website is large or technically complex, such as a webshop with many products.
you are planning to move or redesign your website.
your competitors have held strong positions in the search results for years.
There is also a middle route. Keeping your Google Business Profile up to date, replying to reviews and writing your own copy are often things you can handle perfectly well yourself. A step-by-step plan for local SEO helps you get started. You then leave the technical side, an SEO audit (a thorough check of your site) or a website move to a specialist. That way the knowledge about your customer stays close to hand.
What Google says about DIY and hiring an SEO
Google says a small local business can probably do much of the SEO work itself. Google recommends starting with the SEO Starter Guide, a practical guide to improving your site. If you have little time or little appetite for experimenting, the same guide suggests you consider a professional.
Google says an SEO specialist can, among other things, review your content and site structure, give technical advice, research keywords and provide SEO training.
Before you hire someone, Google recommends asking a series of questions. These three help the most.
Do you follow Google Search Essentials?
These are Google's guidelines, formerly known as the Webmaster Guidelines.
What results do you expect and within what timeframe?
A good answer is concrete and fits your market.
How do you measure success?
Agree in advance which figures you will track, such as visitors from Google or enquiries through your site.
Google says nobody can guarantee the number one spot in Google. If a provider promises you that spot anyway, Google recommends looking for someone else.
Pitfalls on either route
These pitfalls apply whether you do SEO yourself or outsource it. Knowing them saves a lot of repair work.
Tricks that Google lists in its spam policies include hidden text, stuffing pages with keywords and buying links to rank higher. Sites that break those policies risk dropping lower in the results according to Google or even disappearing from them entirely.
A provider or course that promises quick top positions. Google warns against SEOs who guarantee rankings, claim a 'special relationship' with Google or offer priority submission to Google. Steer clear of promises like these straight away.
Handing over Search Console and your account completely. A property is your website as it appears in Search Console. Google says only someone with the owner role in a property can give others permissions. Keep that property in your own name and give a provider user access. You can quickly withdraw that access later according to Google via the Remove access option.
A website move where old addresses point nowhere. Google advises mapping old addresses to new ones and setting up redirects, automatic forwards from an old address to the new one. Even then, your rankings can fluctuate and for a medium-sized site it takes a few weeks or longer according to Google before the new addresses show up. Read up on an SEO migration beforehand if you are planning something like this.
Frequently asked questions about DIY or outsourced SEO
Can a small business do its own SEO?
Often a large part of it. Google writes that a small local business can probably take on much of the work itself. For tricky technical issues or a large website, outside help pays off.
How do you learn SEO yourself?
Start with the SEO Starter Guide from Google. In that guide you can read, among other things, how to check whether Google already knows about your site. The guide also describes a sitemap, a list of your pages for Google, as optional.
Can you do part of your SEO yourself and outsource the rest?
That works perfectly well. For example, you keep your Google Business Profile and your copy up to date yourself, while a specialist handles the technical side or a website move. Agree in advance who does what.

How do you recognise a reliable SEO provider?
A reliable provider never promises you the number one spot, because according to Google nobody can. Also ask for examples of previous work and whether all changes to your site will be shared with you, two questions Google recommends asking.
How long does it take for SEO to deliver results?
Google says a change can take effect within a few hours, while other changes take a few months. Google recommends in its Starter Guide that you usually wait a few weeks before judging whether your work has paid off. Read more in our article on how long SEO takes.
Choosing to outsource?
Next step
On the page about outsourcing SEO, you can read how our team carries out the work for you. Still in two minds? Dominic will think it through with you in a call.
HOW OUTSOURCING SEO WORKS


